1 Molar or 1 Molal, Which is More Concentrated and Why ? With Practical Numerical Example


πŸ” What is Concentration?

Concentration means how much solute is present in a given amount of solvent or solution.
The more solute in a given amount of liquid, the more concentrated the solution is.


πŸ§ͺ What is 1 Molar (1 M)?

  • Molarity (M) = Moles of solute / Liters of solution
  • So, 1 M means: 1 mole of solute is dissolved in 1 liter of the total solution (solute + solvent combined).

πŸ”Έ That 1 liter includes both:

  • The solute (like salt or sugar)
  • The solvent (like water)

πŸ§ͺ What is 1 Molal (1 m)?

  • Molality (m) = Moles of solute / Kilograms of solvent
  • So, 1 m means: 1 mole of solute is dissolved in exactly 1 kilogram of solvent only (not the total solution).

πŸ”Έ The final volume of the solution may be more than 1 liter, but that doesn’t matter in molality. It depends only on the mass of solvent.


βš–οΈ So, Which One Is More Concentrated?

Let’s compare 1 M and 1 m for the same solute (say, NaCl):

🟦 In 1 M solution:

  • 1 mole of NaCl is dissolved in 1 liter of solution.
  • Since solute also takes up space, the amount of water used is less than 1 kg (maybe around 0.95 kg).

🟩 In 1 m solution:

  • 1 mole of NaCl is dissolved in exactly 1 kg of water.
  • The final volume may be more than 1 liter (maybe 1.05 L), but we don’t care about volume in molality.

πŸ‘‰ So, in 1 molal, we’re using less liquid (just 1 kg of water), while in 1 molar, the solution includes more total volume (solute + some extra water).

βœ… Therefore: 1 molal is more concentrated than 1 molar.


πŸ’‘ Simple Analogy:

Imagine making lemon juice πŸ‹:

  • 1 M = 1 spoon of lemon juice in a 1-liter jug of drink
  • 1 m = 1 spoon of lemon juice in exactly 1 kg of water (which is slightly less than 1 liter)

Who do you think will get the sourer drink?
πŸ‘‰ The one with less water – so 1 molal is more concentrated.


πŸ“Œ Key Differences Table:

PropertyMolarity (1 M)Molality (1 m)
Based onVolume of solution (L)Mass of solvent (kg)
Affected by temperature?βœ… Yes (volume changes)❌ No (mass doesn’t change)
ConcentrationLess (more total volume)More (fixed amount of solvent)
Unitsmol/Lmol/kg

Let’s make this very, very simple β€” like a fun story. 😊


πŸ§ͺ Imagine Two Friends Are Making Salt Water:

Friend A makes 1 Molar (1 M) salt water:

  • He takes 1 spoon of salt.
  • Then he adds water until the total water + salt = 1 bottle (1 liter).

πŸ“Œ So he uses less water, because the bottle must fit both salt + water.


Friend B makes 1 Molal (1 m) salt water:

  • He takes 1 spoon of salt.
  • Then he takes exactly 1 kg of water (about 1 full bottle).
  • He does not care how big the final bottle is β€” just uses 1 kg of water.

πŸ“Œ So, he uses more water than Friend A.


πŸ” Who has the stronger (more concentrated) salt water?

Let’s look:

FriendSalt (solute)Water (solvent)Concentration
A (1 M)1 spoonLess than 1 kgMore concentrated βœ…
B (1 m)1 spoon1 kgLess concentrated ❌

βœ… Final Answer (Simple):

βœ”οΈ 1 Molar (1 M) is actually more concentrated than 1 Molal (1 m)
because it uses less water for the same amount of salt.


πŸ’‘ Easy Trick to Remember:

  • Molarity (M) β†’ based on volume β†’ less water used β†’ more concentrated
  • Molality (m) β†’ based on mass (kg of water) β†’ more water used β†’ less concentrated

πŸ”· Best Coaching Center for IIT-JEE, NEET, and Foundations

πŸ”Ή ANAND CLASSES – The best coaching institute for JEE, NEET, and Class 11-12 Foundations.
πŸ”Ή Buy complete study material at πŸ‘‰ https://publishers.anandclasses.co.in/
πŸ”Ή Proprietor: NIRMAL ANAND Educations
πŸ”Ή Written by: Neeraj Anand
πŸ”Ή Published by: Anand Technical Publishers under Anand Classes
πŸ“ž Contact: +91-9463138669
πŸ“§ Email: anandclasses1996@gmail.com

RELATED POST

Er. Neeraj K.Anand is a freelance mentor and writer who specializes in Engineering & Science subjects. Neeraj Anand received a B.Tech degree in Electronics and Communication Engineering from N.I.T Warangal & M.Tech Post Graduation from IETE, New Delhi. He has over 30 years of teaching experience and serves as the Head of Department of ANAND CLASSES. He concentrated all his energy and experiences in academics and subsequently grew up as one of the best mentors in the country for students aspiring for success in competitive examinations. In parallel, he started a Technical Publication "ANAND TECHNICAL PUBLISHERS" in 2002 and Educational Newspaper "NATIONAL EDUCATION NEWS" in 2014 at Jalandhar. Now he is a Director of leading publication "ANAND TECHNICAL PUBLISHERS", "ANAND CLASSES" and "NATIONAL EDUCATION NEWS". He has published more than hundred books in the field of Physics, Mathematics, Computers and Information Technology. Besides this he has written many books to help students prepare for IIT-JEE and AIPMT entrance exams. He is an executive member of the IEEE (Institute of Electrical & Electronics Engineers. USA) and honorary member of many Indian scientific societies such as Institution of Electronics & Telecommunication Engineers, Aeronautical Society of India, Bioinformatics Institute of India, Institution of Engineers. He has got award from American Biographical Institute Board of International Research in the year 2005.